Monthly Archives: October 2009

From the FT:
Why the renminbi has to rise to address imbalances – Martin Feldstein
Close the funding gap for smaller businesses – Nigel Rudd
King’s proposal provides stability in banking sector – Nigel Collin
Goodbye to the pre-crisis trend line – Samuel Brittan

From elsewhere:
Selling stocks short: Ever controversial – Gerald P. Dwyer, Federal Reserve of Atlanta
Swiss Banking Is Finished – Joe Weisenthal, BusinessInsider
Can We Fix Too Big to Fail Without Shrinkage? – Noam Scheiber, The New Republic
What’s so bad about inflation? – David Blanchflower New Statesman
Sustainable Growth? – Tim Duy’s Fed Watch, Economist’s View
Design and effectiveness of fiscal-stimulus programmes – Robert Barro and Charles Redlick, VOXEU
Scientist Monkeys Around With The Economy – NPR audio on primate economics

From the FT:
How to avoid a repeat of the Great Crash – Peter Clarke
Goldman: reasons to be wrathful – Chris Gradel
A three-way split is the most logical
– John Gapper on ‘too big to fail’
Russia’s unsustainable energy model – David Clark

From elsewhere:
A Balanced Global Diet – Nouriel Roubini, RGE Monitor
Chinese railways and speculating pig farmers – Michael Pettis , China Financial Markets
Efficient Market Theory and the Crisis – Jeremy J. Siegel
Futures As Predictors of Commodity Prices – Menzie Chinn, Econbrowser
Turkey Dumps US Dollar For Trade With Iran And China – Joe Weisenthal, BusinessInsider
Why Do Financial Crises Happen in the Fall? – Catherine Rampell, NYT Economix Blog
Are Capital Controls In Fashion Again? – Nouriel Roubini, Forbes

By Ronald McKinnon

This is an updated version of Liquidity traps and the credit crunch, published in this forum on August 13, 2009

Since the onset of the credit crunch and global downturn, governments everywhere have responded to the shortfall in aggregate demand in a textbook Keynesian fashion. They have adopted fiscal stimuli: ramping up government expenditures and cutting taxes. Central banks followed the lead of the Federal Reserve by driving down short-term interest rates toward zero: almost exactly zero for overnight interbank rates in the US, Japan, and Canada, and generally less than 1 per cent in Europe into the autumn of this year.

By Charles Goodhart

It is remarkable how powerful a well-turned phrase can be. There have been many such phrases generated in the course of this crisis, not all of them helpful, indeed in some cases misleading. Examples are: ‘Toxic assets’; ‘If a bank is too big to fail, it is too big’; and particularly relevant here: ‘Banks have become a combination of a casino and a utility.’ While I congratulate John Kay on his authorship of this last, arresting phrase, I am afraid that it is both misleading and wrong-headed.

From the FT:

‘Too big to fail’ is too dumb an idea to keep – John Kay
Obama’s executive pay move is bad policy – Charles Calomiris
Speculators do drive prices, and it’s the developing countries that suffer – Andrew Mold

From elsewhere:

The Case for More Stimulus – New York Times editorial
Enablers of the Housing Bubble – Brad DeLong, with chart on non-agency securitisation, Economist’s View
Financial Crises are different! – Stephen Cecchetti, Marion Kohler, Christian Upper. VOXEU
Latin America and the Caribbean: Finding Space for Countercyclical Fiscal Policy – Nicolás Eyzaguirre, IMFdirect
The National Saving Identity: Private Saving, Household Saving, and Rebalancing – Menzie Chinn, Econbrowser

Image

How did the world economy fall into such a deep hole? It is recovering, but painfully, and after a deep recession, despite unprecedented monetary and fiscal easing. Moreover, how likely is it that a balanced world economy will emerge from this force-feeding? The very fact that such drastic action has been necessary is terrifying. The fact that there is little room for a policy encore is yet more terrifying. Most terrifying of all is that this is not the first time in recent decades the world economy has had to be guided through a post-bubble collapse.

In his latest book – a successor to Valuing Wall Street, which appeared in time to help alert readers avoid the 2000 meltdown – Andrew Smithers of London-based Smithers & Co, provides an invaluable guide to past errors of analysis and policy.* He is a rare guide – a man with a deep understanding of economics and a lifetime’s experience of financial markets. His work helps to explain the stock-market bubble of the 1990s, the fiscal errors of Gordon Brown and the recent credit excess.

The big points of the book are four: first, asset markets are only “imperfectly efficient”; second, it is possible to value markets; third, huge positive deviations from fair value – bubbles – are economically devastating, particularly if associated with credit surges and underpricing of liquidity; and, finally, central banks should try to prick such bubbles. “We must be prepared to consider the possibility that periodic mild recessions are a necessary price for avoiding major ones.” I have been unwilling to accept this view. That is no longer true.

The remainder of this article can be read here. Please post comments below.

From the FT:

In depth: George Soros lectures
Storms lie ahead for politics’ odd couple – Philip Stephens on Mervyn King and George Osborne
We must overturn the status quo in derivatives – Kenneth Griffin

Elsewhere:

Oil prices and bank profitability – Heiko Hesse and Tigran Poghosyan, VOXEU
The Big Banks Get Bigger: Notes – James Surowiecki, The New Yorker
Fixed rates and protectionism, 2009 edition – Paul Krugman, New York  Times
The Panic of ’08: Recession Cause or Effect? – Casey B. Mulligan, NYT Economix Blog
How international reserves and easy money caused the crisis – Guillermo Calvo, VOXEU

By Kumiharu Shigehara

Japan‘s economic expansion stumbled by late 2007, and in the context of the global economic crisis, it has been trapped in the deepest recession of the post-war era. Initially, the impact of the global crisis on the Japanese economy was expected to be limited because Japanese banks and other financial institutions were relatively insulated from financial turmoil. However, between the third quarter of 2008 and the first quarter of this year, Japan’s exports fell at an annual rate of some 55 per cent in volume terms, the sharpest among OECD countries and double the area’s average rate of decline.

From the FT:

Do not ignore the need for financial reform – George Soros
A polite discourse on bankers and bubbles – Wolfgang Münchau
The Fund should help Brazil to tackle inflows – Arvind Subramanian and John Williamson
Grim Britain – FT Editorial

Elsewhere:

Patchwork Fixes, Conflicting Motives, And Other Things To Avoid: Some Lessons From the Regulated Non-Financial Sectors - Peter Fox-Penner, Baseline Scenario
Adjustment and the dollar – Paul Krugman, NYT
Adjustments to the accountability and transparency of the European Central Bank – Sylvester Eijffinger, VOXEU
Low Interest Rates May Be Here To Stay – Joseph E. Gagnon, Peterson Institute
The smartest boys in the alley, early derivatives on the London stock market – Economic History Blog
Why Banks stay big – James Surowiecki, New Yorker

About a month ago, I visited the aero engine factory of Rolls-Royce, in Derby. I was hugely impressed. Making jet engines able to work at extreme temperatures is an extraordinary achievement. Why does the financial industry not work this way? How might we bring the performance of finance close to that of other sophisticated businesses?

Economists' Forum

Debating economics

About this blog Blog guide
Read posts on economics from guest contributors to the FT and share your views. Martin Wolf, the FT's chief economics commentator, often joins the debate.


To comment, please register for free with FT.com and read our policy on submitting comments.

All posts are published in UK time.

Contact martin.wolf@ft.com about the Economists' Forum.

See the full list of FT blogs.

Archive

« Sep Nov »October 2009
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031