Click here to read Martin Wolf’s opening salvo

By Jo Johnson

The ‘bonus’ debate boils down to what type of banking system you want. If it is just utility banking, then kiss goodbye to the City of London and much of the economy of the south-east of England. We do not need hundreds of thousands of people to manage the country’s current accounts and loans to small businesses.

The problem is not just that there would be few takers of any calibre for employment in such tedious institutions, but that they would not be needed. A rapid move towards utility-only banking would be a quick way to kill off the financial services expertise that the City of London and Edinburgh has developed over centuries.

By Martin Wolf

Populism is breaking out, not surprisingly, over bankers’ pay. When an industry has played a huge role in creating what may well be the first depression since the 1930s, that is hardly surprising. Even Lloyd Blankfein, chairman of Goldman Sachs, has admitted the industry screwed up comprehensively. That is pretty obvious now.

The response to the pay curbs is that the high pay is needed to obtain and reward talent. I think that’s nonsense. Do we really want to reward the “talent” that has just brought down the world economy?

So what makes sense here? I suggest there are four questions.

The debate over bankers’ bonuses has polarised opinion, even within the Financial Times. FT.com invited Martin Wolf, our chief economics commentator, and the editor of the Lex column to share their spirited discussions with readers.

Read these recent Lex notes on the question of pay and bonuses:

Give the dogs a bonus

Capping executive pay

Sober CEOs

About Lex vs Martin Wolf

This blog is no longer updated but it remains open as an archive.

The debate over bankers' bonuses has polarised opinion, even within the Financial Times. FT.com invited Jo Johnson, Lex column editor and Martin Wolf, our chief economics commentator, to share their spirited discussions with readers. Other FT writers have also joined the debate.

Archives

FT Blogs