Once upon a time, the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee sounded like a group of nine individuals with differing views. One of the most interesting aspects of Mark Carney’s arrival is the monotone now coming from the interest-rate setting committee.
It has been noticed: for example Fathom Consulting put this slide up at its recent monetary policy forum.
In a note last week, JP Morgan also made a rather damming comparison between the BoE’s reticence to acknowledge any discussion over a new form of guidance with the Federal Reserve’s minutes which demonstrated a healthy debate over the options. Allan Monks, the author of the note, concluded:
” In our view, the lack of discussion about the presentation and specifics of this new ‘framework’, or the consideration of any alternatives, does not suggest the committee as a whole is strongly invested in it. While Governor Carney may suggest policy-setting has undergone another innovation, the rest of the MPC has merely acquiesced and views the changes through a different lens.”