Saturday Jul 5 2008
All times are London time

Search Quotes in the FT.com site
FT Logo

February 5, 2007

Irrational dislike of Singapore

I am back in Singapore for the first time for almost a decade. Inevitably, it is a bit of a trip down memory lane – the palm trees, the skyscrapers, the shopping. The government.

Ah yes, the government. I’m afraid that my strongest impression of Singapore was shaped by what happened when my reporting inadvertently setting off a row between The Economist and the Singaporean authorities. This escalated to the point where the magazine’s circulation was severely restricted in Singapore – with the threat of an eventual ban. I cannot remember the full details of the dispute – something to do with the publication of letters from the government. And, to be honest, it is probably not in my interests to make too great an effort to remember the details, since the Singaporeans appear to have strong feelings about repeating a libel.

But I do remember the feeling of being closely watched whenever I returned to Singapore after the great Economist row. I don’t think I was being paranoid. Why else would the girl escorting me to my room in the Shangri-La hotel have squeaked – “This is so exciting”, as she ushered me in. Maybe it was just my aura of brooding masculinity – but somehow I doubt it.

I was also pretty sure that my hotel phone was tapped. I took my revenge on eavesdroppers by having long conversations of staggering banality with my wife. (To be honest, we don’t really have to make a special effort to do this.) I didn’t really mind the thought that I was being listened to – if anything, I was rather flattered. I had nothing important to announce.

In fact, if anybody from the Singaporean security services happens to be reading this blog, I’d just like to say – “No hard feelings, lads.”

Maybe I’m just falling victim to nostalgia – but I’m feeling more pro-Singaporean these days. Because the Singaporeans are so expert at putting the foreign media under intense pressure, many journalists develop a deep grudge against the place. And given how many opposition politicians have ended up in court over the years, it is true that you have to be pretty courageous to take on the ruling People’s Action Party, which has been in power ever since Singaporean independence in 1965.

But there is also no doubt that the average Singaporean has a much better life than the average citizen of any other neighbouring South-East Asian country. It is not just that Singaporeans are richer than Indonesians or Malaysians. They are also, in general, much less exposed to the arbitrary exercise of power. All the same I would probably advise a young Singaporean to think of a career in dentistry or engineering, rather than opposition politics or journalism.

6 Responses to “Irrational dislike of Singapore”

Comments

  1. It’s no surprise that some journalists “develop a deep grudge against” Singapore since the Government uses its vaunted legal system to discredit their allegations and demand either an apology or a penalty. (They did learn from the best!)

    As in any law-abiding society, if you have the truth on your side - why would you be ‘paranoid’? The rules of engagement are clearly spelt out in Singapore - either you play by those rules, or you take your marbles somewhere else.

    Posted by: Saha | February 7th, 2007 at 3:52 pm | Report this comment
  2. Gideon, I would give a lot to be monitored like that and to so exquisitely disclose it.
    The Singaporeans, for their part, are walking a fine line between conducting an open economy and suppressing political criticism with Stasi-type behaviour. At some point they will choke off capital inflows, not least in funds management.

    Posted by: Taffey Thomas | February 8th, 2007 at 2:42 am | Report this comment
  3. nice blog entry.

    singapore has changed and improved quite a bit over the years. it aint as paranoid as before but i guess certain things will take time to change.

    woof woof

    Posted by: sophie | February 10th, 2007 at 2:45 pm | Report this comment
  4. Alas, foreign peri-pathetics like u always like to flatter yourselves that the Govt pays u the kind of attention u imagine u deserve!

    Posted by: Auntie Lucy | February 11th, 2007 at 2:05 pm | Report this comment
  5. Auntie Lucy,

    If they almost banned the economist due to his article, wouldn’t that justify his paranoia in your mind?

    Also, If SIngapore’s chief function is to be teh Asian hub for finance-related industries, this is a business in which image plays an important part. Thus, the actions of journalists, especially for widely respected finance related publications would obviously be of importance.

    I don’t understand the value of your remark, to be quite honest. Without any sarcasm, I would love for you explain it further?

    Posted by: Franz Depinay | February 26th, 2007 at 7:54 pm | Report this comment
  6. I am staying in Spore currently and actually most of the objective comments on Spore govt policies are inaccessible. many of the related websites are blocked. I would like to know more about Spore policy’s true colour. Thanks for your help.

    Posted by: Nguyet Ho | February 22nd, 2008 at 7:42 pm | Report this comment

Post a comment

Comment Policy



As a final step before posting the comment, please type the two words you see in the image beloweight numbers in the audio clip; this test is to prevent automated robots from posting comments.


More FT Blogs and Forums

  • Clive Crook's blog The FT's chief Washington commentator blogs about intersection of politics and economics

  • Economists' Forum Leading economists and the FT's chief economics commentator, Martin Wolf, debate the big issues

  • The Undercover Economist Tim Harford's blog on economics in everyday life

  • Willem Buiter's Maverecon The LSE professor blogs on 'economics, politics, ethics, religion, culture, free and open source software (FOSS), and whatever'

  • John Gapper's blog FT chief business commentator talks about business, finance, media and technology

  • Management Blog A forum for the latest thinking about the issues that preoccupy managers around the world

  • FT Alphaville Instant market news and commentary for finance professionals

  • Brussels Blog By our Brussels writers

  • Westminster Blog By our UK Parliament writers

  • Dear Lucy Columnist Lucy Kellaway and readers solve your workplace woes

  • FT Tech Blog Our San Francisco and world correspondents look at the intersection of technology and business

Further Reading