June 28, 2007
The new man at the Foreign Office
For reasons too dull to disclose, I am currently in Finland. However, I am following the British cabinet re-shuffle closely and I see that we have a new foreign secretary.
David Miliband is young (41) and clever – unlike his predecessor Margaret Beckett. She was last seen sobbing inconsolably in the House of Commons, after Tony Blair’s farewell statement. Gordon Brown put a consoling arm around her. Then – that evening – he sacked her. That’s politics.
So what will Miliband be like as foreign secretary? Point one – he is obsessed by global warming. His last job was as environment secretary and he became increasingly pre-occupied by climate change. I would guess that his top personal priority will be working on the post-Kyoto agreement.
He is also at home in the United States. Like many of the brighter young politicians in the Labour Party, he did graduate work in the US.
But a few years ago, Miliband was also given close exposure to the machinations of the European Union. He was appointed as Tony Blair’s personal representative to a group of “wise men”, working on the “Laeken declaration” on the future of Europe – which laid the groundwork for the ill-fated European constitutional convention. Miliband strove mightily to get on with Belgium’s arch-federalist prime minister, Guy Verhofstadt, who had convened the group – and even got Verhofstadt to visit his constituency in South Shields in northern England. Apparently Miliband is faintly embarrassed by the whole Laeken experience and would prefer it if people forgot it.
Still, his ability to get on with Verhofstadt illustrates another of his qualities. He is very personable. EU civil servants, who have watched him in action at the Council of Ministers, say that he works the room assiduously – and that he makes a point of trying to speak last in a debate, so that his intervention can summarise and shape the conclusions. He will be well-suited to the diplomatic side of the job. The fact that he looks very young, however, might be a handicap in Asia – where people take you more seriously if you have a bit of grey hair.
The Foreign Office is likely to be pleased by the arrival of Miliband. The big story of the last couple of years has been the sidelining of the Foreign Office, and the increasing centralisation of power and decision-making in 10 Downing Street. Having the less-than-impressive Margaret Beckett to fight the Foreign Office’s corner was not much help. The professional diplomats will be hoping that - because Gordon Brown’s interests are so heavily economic - the Foreign Office under Miliband might undergo a bit of a revival.
But there is an alternative and darker scenario. Even though Tony Blair did run foreign policy from Downing Street – his closest aides were still drawn from the Foreign Office. Brown – on the other hand – has surrounded himself with Treasury people. (The new Downing Street Europe adviser, John Cunliffe, is ex-Treasury). Brown is also a known control-freak, who has reason to be wary of Miliband – who was touted as the likeliest man to fight him for the Labour leadership. So it is entirely possible that – for all his gifts – David Miliband may still be cut out of Brown’s inner circle.











And then one has to wonder whether he is only foreign secretary for those parts of the world that Mr. Blair isn’t going to cover in his new job.
Posted by: Felix Drost, Amsterdam | June 28th, 2007 at 6:17 pm | Report this commentI think the appointment of Mark Malloch Brown (as minister for Africa Asia and the UN) is probably a good indication of what Gordon Brown’s opinion of Blair’s foreign policies are:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/guardianpolitics/story/0,,2114523,00.html
P
Posted by: Pacifist | June 29th, 2007 at 12:30 pm | Report this comment“For reasons too dull to disclose, I am currently in Finland.”
Posted by: Patrik Åkerman | June 29th, 2007 at 5:24 pm | Report this commentI can only hope that you are enjoying the Savonlinna Opera Festival currently going on. Due make sure to hob-nob a bit, and if you happen to catch Swedens Foreign Minister (who wrote on his blog that he was going) do write about it.
Dear Patrik,
For reasons too dull to divulge, I am going to have to skip the opera tomorrow night, and return to London. But a very clever piece of detective work on your part. I did hear Bildt speak tonight. He was rather good and spoke with great energy and passion.The theme of his speech seemed to be that we Europeans will inherit the earth.
Posted by: Gideon Rachman | June 29th, 2007 at 9:40 pm | Report this commentIt’s hard to disagree about the mediocrity of Margaret Beckett at the Foreign Office. She had come from the Environment brief with a mixed reputation, and part of her downfall has been the way her decisions there have been found to be wanting since (remember the payouts to farmers fiasco?)
It’s interesting you mention Milliband’s interest in climate change. Beckett has been banging that drum at the FO, to a largely uninterested audience.
The parallels do not end there. For all his charm and his media nous, most observers did not rate Milliband terribly highly in his last brief. Indeed, the flooding preparations were his remit. So, a Blairite climate-obsessed former environment secretary at the FO? I think Milliband’s age could be the last of his problems.
Posted by: SP | July 2nd, 2007 at 12:13 am | Report this commentThanks for the compliment.
Since it is quite unusual for ex-Prime Ministers to join a subsequent cabinet there was some speculation in the Swedish press that Mr. Bildt only sees his current job as a stepping stone towards becoming President of the European Commission (or some similar job for an European elder statesman). I would very much like to hear your views on
a) The likelihood that he wants such a job
b) The likelihood that he can get it
Maybe you could work a response into any one of your upcoming posts?
Posted by: Patrik Åkerman | July 2nd, 2007 at 4:08 pm | Report this commentThanks in advance.