March 12, 2008
The Fed is delaying the day of reckoning
By Charles Wyplosz
In 1971, with the greenback weak and falling, US Treasury secretary John Connally famously told the rest of the world that the US dollar was “our currency and your problem”. Thirty years later, with the dollar strong and still rising, Robert Rubin, his successor, no less famously stated that “a strong dollar is in the interest of the United States”.
These days, because the dollar is weak and falling, we would have expected US officials to return to Connally’s mantra but they unexpectedly chose Rubin’s. On reflection, glorifying a strong dollar when it is so weak means they do not care. Connally without compassion, if you prefer.
Jean-Claude Trichet, president of the European Central Bank, is thereby left bemoaning “excessive exchange rate moves”. This, too, is an extraordinary statement. In the past week the dollar has barely lost 1 per cent vis a vis the euro. That is significant, but “excessive”? Yes, he may be reacting to the 6 per cent dollar depreciation in the past month. Or to the 17 per cent change over the past 12 months. Or perhaps the 31 per cent depreciation since the dollar was last strongish in late November 2005.
Well, currencies float. They are bound to be sometimes overvalued and sometimes undervalued. This is what they do and these numbers are not especially large by historical standards. Margaret Thatcher, former UK prime minister, was right when she said that exchange rates were a matter for markets to decide.
Of course, markets react to monetary policies. As the US economy faces a recession, a weak dollar is in the country’s interests. As inflation exceeds its own definition of price stability, a strong euro is in the interests of the eurozone. End of story? Not quite. (Continued)
Charles Wyplosz is professor of economics at the Graduate Institute of Geneva. The remainder of his column can be read here. Comment from our expert panel and guest members can be read below.
